Is it really all about message passing in Smalltalk?

Question

I'm new to Smalltalk and I'm impressed with the fact that there are only just 6 keywords in the language (self, super, true, false, nil & thisContext), and how pure it is in having almost everything as message passing, eg. looping using whileTrue, if/else using ifTrue, etc ... which are way different from what I'm used to in other languages.

Yet, there are cases where I just cannot make sense of how message passing really fit in, these include:

• the assignment operator :=
• the cascading operator ;
• the period operator .
• the way to create a set #( ... )

These aren't message passing, right?

Answer 1

As you've discovered, there's still some actual Smalltalk syntax. Block construction, literal strings/symbols/comments, local variable declaration (|...|), and returning (^) are a few things you didn't mention which are also syntax.

Some extensions (e.g. #(...), which typically creates an Array, not a set) are certainly expressible otherwise, for example #(1 2 3) is equivalent to Array with: 1 with: 2 with: 3; they're just there to make the code easier to read and write.