Search code examples
javascripttypescriptwebpackwebpack-2babeljs

Why do some projects that use typescript/webpack also use babel to finish compilation

I've noticed some web projects using typescript and webpack also use babel to finish off the compilation. For example, they use ts to compile to ES2015 and then use babel to compile to es5. Why not just use ts directly to compile to es5?

Is it in the case the project also has js that needs to be compiled so they just use babel for everything? Or what am I missing?

Thanks.

Solution

  • There's a few possible reasons for this.

    1. They're using Babel to automatically polyfill - TypeScript only performs syntactic transformations, leaving the user to figure out what runtime libraries they'll need to be around (e.g. Promise, Symbol, etc). This allows you to decide which implementation of these polyfills will work the best for you, but it can be a pain. Babel spares you the burden of thinking about that. It's a tradeoff.
    2. They need it for a custom transformation - TypeScript has a transform pipeline, but it's only accessible when you use the TypeScript API at this point in time. If you're already using Babel and want to start using TypeScript, but you're already using a transform, this is a reasonable compromise.
    3. It was created when TypeScript didn't support compiling generators to ES5 (or even back when TypeScript didn't support async/await in ES5) - TypeScript has supported async/await in ES5 since 2.1, and has supported generators behind the downlevelIteration flag since 2.3. Before that, users often relied on Babel to pick up the slack, but Babel isn't needed here anymore.
    4. It was created before Webpack 2 and the project used a specific way of importing modules - TypeScript has an allowSyntheticDefaultImport option which tells TypeScript that default imports can be used to import certain modules. Babel supports this behavior, but Webpack didn't until Webpack 2 came out. Babel isn't needed here anymore for newer versions of Webpack.

    This might not be the complete set of reasons, but it's a few I can think of off the top of my head.