In Python, __new__
is used to initialize immutable types and __init__
typically initializes mutable types. If __init__
were removed from the language, what could no longer be done (easily)?
For example,
class A:
def __init__(self, *, x, **kwargs):
super().__init__(**kwargs)
self.x = x
class B(A):
def __init__(self, y=2, **kwargs):
super().__init__(**kwargs)
self.y = y
Could be rewritten using __new__
like this:
class A_N:
def __new__(cls, *, x, **kwargs):
obj = super().__new__(cls, **kwargs)
obj.x = x
return obj
class B_N(A_N):
def __new__(cls, y=2, **kwargs):
obj = super().__new__(cls, **kwargs)
obj.y = y
return obj
Clarification for scope of question: This is not a question about how __init__
and __new__
are used or what is the difference between them. This is a question about what would happen if __init__
were removed from the language. Would anything break? Would anything become a lot harder or impossible to do?
Everything you can do in __init__
can also be done in __new__
.
Then, why use __init__
?
Because you don't have to store instance in variable (obj
in your example code), and later bother returning it. You can focus on what you realy want to do – initializing mutable object.