Search code examples
assemblyadditionmipsmove

Difference between "addi" and "add" for pseudoinstruction "move" in MIPS?

For this pseudoinstruction:

move $rt, $rs

Are both the addi and add assembly code acceptable? So could I use either

add $rt, $rs, $0

or

addi $rt, $rs, $0

?

Edit: I think I made a mistake with addi

add $rt, $rs, $0

would be the same as

addi $rt, $rs, 0

since add adds registers, and I need a constant for the immediate for addi

Solution

  • The addi instruction requires an immediate operand rather than a register, so the $0 would actually be 0:

    add   $rt, $rs, $0
addi  $rt, $rs, 0

    Both will work and have all the needed information encoded into the instruction itself):

    add   $d, $s, $t
    0000 00ss ssst tttt dddd d000 0010 0000
addi  $t, $s, i
    0010 00ss ssst tttt iiii iiii iiii iiii

    However, it would be more usual to just use the zero-locked $0 register in this particular case since that is, after all, its purpose.

    I would also tend to use the unsigned variant however, since I seem to recall there may be extra overflow checking done for signed instructions:

    addu  $rt, $rs, $0