For method of type T, what should be its 'inferred' type when it takes two <? super T> arguments?

Question

There is a method in hamcrest library:

package org.hamcrest.core

...

public static <T> Matcher<T> allOf(Matcher<? super T> first, Matcher<? super T> second) {
    List<Matcher<? super T>> matchers = new ArrayList<Matcher<? super T>>(2);
    matchers.add(first);
    matchers.add(second);
    return allOf(matchers);
}

In my code, I call this method with first being Matcher<Object> and second being Matcher<SomeException>.

And now:

• When I compile it with Eclipse with 1.6 target, it makes <T> Matcher<SomeException>.
• When I compile it with javac 1.7 with 1.6 target, it makes <T> Matcher<SomeException>.
• When I compile it with javac 1.6 with 1.6 target, it makes <T> Matcher<Object>

The question is, what <T> should be in such case?

My understanding is, that there is a bug in javac 1.6 and it should be Matcher<SomeException>, as this is a common type for input arguments (SomeException is a subtype of Object) and then, it is 100% sure, that returned Matcher will be Matcher<SomeException>.

Am I right? And is there any way to force javac 1.6 to behave properly?

Answer 1

The compiler will do an inference based on actual arguments. It will start out with the initial constraints of Matcher<Object> << Matcher<? super T> and Matcher<SomeException> << Matcher<? super T>. From that it will infer the constraints T << Object and T << SomeException. Object will be eliminated when the minimal erased candidate set is constructed. The remaining candidate SomeException will (eventually :D) be substituted for T.

So far we've shown eclipse and JDK7 behave correctly in this case. I don't think there is any way to force javac to behave correctly as well. You can either explicitly state the type argument or use JDK7 (specifying source and target to be 6).