Search code examples
windowscommand-linecygwinemulationgnuwin32

GnuWin32 or Cygwin - from a programmers point of view

For a programmer with Linux skills and a love of the command line, what is better to use on Windows - Cygwin or GnuWin32?

I tried to find a good comparison or a list of differences but couldn't find anything remotely complete. Also, I wondered whether this should be a superuser.com question, but decided against it, because I'm asking precisely for use of the tool for a programmer.

I'd like to know the common pitfalls and restrictions of each of the solutions. Interoperability with windows is an important issue, for my main development is done in MSVC...

Solution

  • It is absolutely no contest

    GnuWin32 does not include Bash

    This is a critical part of the Cygwin distribution. Switching from cmd.exe to Bash was a huge boon to my productivity. cmd.exe is cripped in comparison to Bash.

    GnuWin32 is old

    Many program go years without being updated.

    • tar 2003
    • coreutils 2005
    • zlib 2005
    • make 2006
    • wget 2008

    I would not use GnuWin32 unless I had no other choice.