.Skip().Take() on Entity Framework Navigation Properties is executing SELECT * on my SQL Server

Question

I have a method on my generated partial class like this:

var pChildren = this.Children
    .Skip(skipRelated)
    .Take(takeRelated)
    .ToList();

When I look at my SQL Server, I can see the generated code is doing a SELECT *.* FROM Children This code is taken directly from my class, I have verified that the order of my Skip/Take is BEFORE my .ToList.

If I remove the .ToList, that line is fast (and no SQL is sent to my DB), but the moment I try to foreach over the results, I get the same SQL sent to my DB: SELECT *.* FROM Children.

Is there something special I need to do when using .Skip and .Take on the navigation properties of my entities?

update

I'll try to get the actual SQL generated, I'm not currently setup for that. I found the first one because it shows up in SSMS's "recenty expensive queries" list.

Running this:

var pChildren = this.Children
    //.Skip(skipRelated)
    //.Take(takeRelated)
    .ToList();

returns ~4,000,000 rows and takes ~25 seconds.

Running this:

var pChildren = this.Children
    //.Skip(skipRelated)
    .Take(takeRelated)
    .ToList();

returns ~4,000,000 rows and takes ~25 seconds.

As I said, I'll grab the SQL generated for these and pose them up as well.

Answer 1

The problem is that you are performing a LINQ-to-Object query when you query a child collection like that. EF will load the whole collection and perform the query in memory.

If you are using EF 4 you can query like this

var pChildren = this.Children.CreateSourceQuery()
                 .OrderBy(/* */).Skip(skipRelated).Take(takeRelated);

In EF 4.1

var pChildren = context.Entry(this)
                   .Collection(e => e.Children)
                   .Query()
                   .OrderBy(/* */).Skip(skipRelated).Take(takeRelated)
                   .Load();