How to use two if statements in C#?

Question

This is my code for an ATM, but somehow when I press the number 2 on the numpad I get my else statement that there was no choice for this number.

Console.WriteLine("What is your name? ");
string userName = Console.ReadLine();
Console.WriteLine("You are: " + userName);
Console.WriteLine("How much money do you have? ");
string Balance = Console.ReadLine();
float startBalance = float.Parse(Balance);

Console.WriteLine(userName + ", your balance is " + startBalance + " EUR");
Console.WriteLine("Press 1 for WITHDRAWAL");
Console.WriteLine("Press 2 for DEPOSIT");


if (Console.ReadKey().Key == ConsoleKey.NumPad1)
{
    Console.ReadLine();
    Console.WriteLine("How much money do you wish to withdraw? ");
    string Withdrawal = Console.ReadLine();
    float wBalance = float.Parse(Withdrawal);

    Console.WriteLine("Your new balance is " + (startBalance - wBalance) + " EUR");
    Console.ReadLine();
    Environment.Exit(0);

} 



if (Console.ReadKey().Key == ConsoleKey.NumPad2)
{
    Console.ReadLine();
    Console.WriteLine("How much money do you wish to deposit? ");
    string Deposit = Console.ReadLine();
    float dBalance = float.Parse(Deposit);

    Console.WriteLine("Your new balance is " + (startBalance - dBalance) + " EUR");
    Console.ReadLine();
    Environment.Exit(0);

}

else Console.WriteLine("There was no choice for this number");

Answer 1

Copy + Paste is evil: please, note that subtracting (adding expected) deposit

"Your new balance is " + (startBalance - dBalance) + " EUR"

is a typical copy + paste error.

Instead of copying yourself, let's extract a method:

private static float ReadFloat(string title) {
  // keep asking user...
  while (true) {
    if (!string.IsNullOrWhiteSpace(title))
      Console.WriteLine(title);

    if (!float.TryParse(Console.ReadLine(), out float result))
      Console.WriteLine("Syntax error. Please, try again.");
    else if (result < 0)
      Console.WriteLine("Negative sum is not allowed. Please, try again.");
    else
      return result; // ... until valid value is provided
  }
}

Then use it

...

Console.WriteLine("Press 1 for WITHDRAWAL");
Console.WriteLine("Press 2 for DEPOSIT");

// Ask user once - Console.ReadKey().Key - then operate with his/her choice 
var choice = Console.ReadKey().Key;

// balance change (either negative - withdraw or positive - deposit)
float delta = 
    choice == ConsoleKey.NumPad1 ? -ReadFloat("How much money do you wish to withdraw?")
  : choice == ConsoleKey.NumPad2 ?  ReadFloat("How much money do you wish to deposit?")
  : 0f;

if (delta != 0) {
  Console.WriteLine($"Your new balance is {startBalance + delta} EUR");
  Console.ReadLine();
  Environment.Exit(0);
}
else 
  Console.WriteLine("There was no choice for this number");