Basically what I want is this:
first.name.com:25565 -> 127.0.0.1:25562
second.name.com:25565 -> 127.0.0.1:25565
This is for some minecraft server's I'm hosting.
Ok, so here's what I ended up doing:
mc.name.com is pointed at the server's hostname using a CNAME record
The next record I added was an SRV record to make 25565 point at 25562 (or whatever port I need it to be)
_minecraft._tcp.mc.muchieman.com
SRV
900
0 5 25562 mc.muchieman.com.
900 being TLS, 0 being priority, 5 being weight, 25562 being the port to point to