I was trying to implement observable waiting for onNext
action to complete before proceeding with next operation. Only way I found working is using SemaphoreSlim
. Does Reactive have any way to do that without use of SemaphoreSlim
? I couldn't find any.
SemaphoreSlim _semaphoreSlim = new SemaphoreSlim(1,1);
subject.Window(() => subject.Throttle(TimeSpan.FromMilliseconds(500)))
.SelectMany(c => c.ToList())
.Subscribe(async x =>
{
await _semaphoreSlim.WaitAsync();
try
{
//await Async code here
}
finally
{
_semaphoreSlim.Release();
}
});
To start with I created a sample Media_Load_Async
that simulates what you're doing.
static int max = 5;
static Random random = new Random();
static TimeSpan[] delays = Enumerable.Range(0, max).Select(x => TimeSpan.FromSeconds(random.Next(5) + 2)).ToArray();
async Task<Unit> Media_Load_Async(int index, TimeSpan delay)
{
Console.WriteLine($"Start {index} - {delay}");
await Task.Delay(delay);
Console.WriteLine($"End {index}");
return Unit.Default;
}
If I run this simple query then I get the results that you're trying to avoid:
Observable
.Range(0, max)
.Subscribe(async x => await Media_Load_Async(x, delays[x]));
Start 0 - 00:00:05
Start 1 - 00:00:06
Start 2 - 00:00:02
Start 3 - 00:00:06
Start 4 - 00:00:04
End 2
End 4
End 0
End 3
End 1
If I put in your SemaporeSlim
code I get what I think you want:
SemaphoreSlim _semaphoreSlim = new SemaphoreSlim(1, 1);
Observable
.Range(0, max)
.Subscribe(async x =>
{
await _semaphoreSlim.WaitAsync();
try
{
await Media_Load_Async(x, delays[x]);
}
finally
{
_semaphoreSlim.Release();
}
});
Start 0 - 00:00:04
End 0
Start 1 - 00:00:03
End 1
Start 2 - 00:00:06
End 2
Start 3 - 00:00:04
End 3
Start 4 - 00:00:03
End 4
Next, if I move the call to Media_Load_Async
to inside the query itself then I'm back to the original issue:
Observable
.Range(0, max)
.SelectMany(x => Observable.FromAsync(() => Media_Load_Async(x, delays[x])))
.Subscribe();
Start 0 - 00:00:06
Start 1 - 00:00:02
Start 2 - 00:00:06
Start 3 - 00:00:05
Start 4 - 00:00:02
End 4
End 1
End 3
End 0
End 2
But if I change out the SelectMany
for a Select
/Concat
pair then I get what you want without a SemaphoreSlim
:
Observable
.Range(0, max)
.Select(x => Observable.FromAsync(() => Media_Load_Async(x, delays[x])))
.Concat()
.Subscribe();
Start 0 - 00:00:04
End 0
Start 1 - 00:00:05
End 1
Start 2 - 00:00:02
End 2
Start 3 - 00:00:06
End 3
Start 4 - 00:00:06
End 4