In Prolog, especially in it's metaprogramming aspects, people often talk about ground and non-ground variables. As well as using predicates such as var/1, nonvar/1 and ground/1. But what exactly is the distincion between them?
My current understanding is the following:
Is this correct?
Nearly.
If var(X)
then variable X
designates something that is uninstantiated, a "hole". X
is a "fresh variable". Note: That predicate should really be named fresh(...)
. Whether X
is a variable is actually a question about the program text. But what we want to know is whether what is in between the parentheses is a fresh variable (at the moment that call is made, because, quite non-logically, that can change.)
nonvar(X)
is just the complement of var(X)
, same as \+ var(X)
. Whatever is between the parentheses designates something (if it is a variable) or is something (if it is a non-variable term, as in nonvar(foo)
) that is not a "hole".
ground(X)
means that whatever is between the parenthese designates something or is something that has no holes in its structure (in effect, no holes at the term's leaves).
Some test code. I expected the compiler to issue more warnings than it did.
:- begin_tests(var_nonvar).
% Amazingly, the compiler does not warn about the code below.
test("var(duh) is always false", fail) :-
var(duh).
% Amazingly, the compiler does not warn about the code below.
test("var(X) is true if X is a fresh variable (X designates a 'hole')") :-
var(_).
% Compiler warning: " Singleton variable, Test is always true: var(X)"
test("var(X) is true if X is a fresh variable (X designates a 'hole')") :-
var(X).
% The hole designated by X is filled with f(_), which has its own hole.
% the result is nonvar (and also nonground)
test("var(X) maybe true but become false as computation progresses") :-
var(X),X=f(_),nonvar(X).
test("var(X) is false otherwise") :-
var(_).
% The hole is designated by an anonymous variable
test("a fresh variable is not ground, it designates a 'hole'", fail) :-
ground(_).
% Both hhe holes are designated by anonymous variables
test("a structure with 'holes' at the leaves is non-ground", fail) :-
ground(f(_,_)).
test("a structure with no 'holes' is ground") :-
ground(f(x,y)).
test("a structure with no 'holes' is ground, take 2") :-
X=f(x,y), ground(X).
% var/1 or ground/1 are questions about the state of computation,
% not about any problem in logic that one models. For example:
test("a structure that is non-ground can be filled as computation progresses") :-
K=f(X,Y), \+ ground(f(X,Y)), X=x, Y=y, ground(f(X,Y)).
:- end_tests(var_nonvar).