Search code examples
emacsoptional-parametersemacs26

invalid-function in emacs 26 but works in emacs 25

This works in emacs 25:

(setq custom-keymap (copy-keymap global-map))

(defun custom-def (keys func &optional file &optional global-p)
  (define-key custom-keymap keys func)
  (if global-p (global-set-key keys func))
  (if file (autoload func file "[custom autoload]" t)))

(custom-def [delete] 'delete-char)

But when I call custom-def in emacs 26 I get an invalid-function error. I isolated it to the &optional parameters. I removed those two args and custom-def works.

So what changed between 25 and 26? What am I missing here? I want the flexible ARGLIST that works in emacs 25.

Solution

  • Use optional just once in the parameter list- the following parameters will all be optional [other keywords can follow as well - see info(elisp) Functions].

    (defun custom-def (keys func &optional file global-p)
  ;; ...
  )

    [I'm not sure what the change was - perhaps duplicated parameter checking was added?]