Composition vs. Inheritance
For a UML Class Diagram, if a class A has a composition relationship with another class B, does it work like inheritance? I know that the class A cannot exist without class b but does class A inherit the attributes and methods from class B?
Composition over inheritance
In OO design, a common advice is to prefer composition over inheritance. This might mislead to think that there is a relation between these two different concepts:
- Inheritance is about a relation between classes.
- Composition is a about relations between objects of classes.
Even more misleading: the "composition" used in the general OO literature corresponds in general to a simple UML association and is not to be understood as restrictive as the UML "composition".
Inheritance is about generalisation and specialisation
If class D inherits from B, it means that D specialises a more general concept B:
- It has all the properties and operations of
B(without need to repeat them in the diagram), - It can have additional properties and operations that are not relevant for
B, and - It can perform some operations of
Bdifferently. - Any object of class
Dis also an object of classBfor its full lifetime. This is why we speak of a "Is a" relationship.
Naive example (just for the illustration):
Composition is about association of objects of very different classes
If class B "composes" (has a composition association with) C, it means that the B object can be associated with different C objects over its lifetime. Anf that objects of class C :
- always belong to a
Bobject that owns it. This is why we sometimes speak of a "has a" relationship; - will not survive its owning
Bobject .
Caution: UML composition is about an exclusive ownership. In the OO literature, the term "composition" often refers to weaker associations without any ownership or even exclusivity.
Naive example (just for the illustration):
- Difference between 'this' and 'self' in programming languages
- Error when creating an array of derived objects
- What is Inversion of Control?
- Why can't I overload constructors in PHP?
- Class variables of same type as the class
- How would I translate a Haskell type class into F#?
- Behaviour of passing struct as a parameter to a CUDA kernel
- Create a Python User() class that both creates new users and modifies existing users
- Inheriting from too many abstract classes?
- Does JavaScript have the interface type (such as Java's 'interface')?
- "A method should do one thing, once and only once" - what does that mean?
- Is it possible to create groups/layers in method chaining in Python?
- How to build a generic repository
- Idiomatic way for a subclass to return a widget?
- How to write -get script for oo::configurable if property itself has name value
- Insert function for a matrix in OCaml is not working
- Where and why do we use __toString() in PHP?
- Javascript : Interface and DTO
- What is the purpose of Serialization in Java?
- Class Reference as Property
- Can I create my own classes or units in Inno Setup?
- Ternary operator syntax error in class declaration
- How does the Liskov Substitution Principle works with type specialization in concrete implementations of abstract classes?
- C# Changing a Class in Production - What is the Best Practice when using the Open/Closed Principle?
- Creating a Custom class of Label and passing arguments from the main window with Custom TKinter and Python
- How to extend base class logic while being able to assign derived classes to it
- Doubts about the use of polymorphism, and also about how is polymorphism related to casting?
- OO design and circular dependencies
- JavaScript private methods
- Why are unnamed namespaces used and what are their benefits?