Search code examples
c++templateslambdalanguage-lawyerc++20

How to provide template arguments to a lambda with a call operator template


For c++20 it is proposed to add the following syntax for generic lambdas p0428r2.pdf

auto f = []<typename T>( T t ) {};

But the current implementation in gcc 8 did not accept the following instantiation:

f<std::string>("");

Is that a implementation bug in gcc or a missing language feature? I know we talk about a proposal and not a approved specification.

Complete example ( with comparison to template function syntax ):

template <typename T> void n( T t ) { std::cout << t << std::endl; }

auto f = []<typename T>( T t ) { std::cout << t << std::endl; };

int main()
{
    f<std::string>("Hello");  // error!
    n<std::string>("World");
}

complains with following error:

main.cpp:25:22: error: expected primary-expression before '>' token f("Hello");


Solution

  • The result of a lambda expression is not a function; it is a function object. That is, it is a class type that has an operator() overload on it. So this:

    auto f = []<typename T>( T t ) {};
    

    Is equivalent to this:

    struct unnamed
    {
      template<typename T>
      void operator()(T t) {}
    };
    
    auto f = unnamed{};
    

    If you want to explicitly provide template arguments to a lambda function, you have to call operator() explicitly:

    f.operator()</* template arguments ... */>(parameters);