Using LiveData with Data Binding

Question

With the stabilization of Android Architecture Components I started updating all my basic ViewModels to the new implementation ofViewModel. In my understanding, the usage of LiveData is recommended to hold the Model class since it handles the lifecycle better.

I like using Data Binding because it makes the code clearer in Java/Kotlin side and it is not needed to "watch" the value changes to update the UI. However the layout using Data Binding only watch data changes if the Model (or the ViewModel) extends BaseObservable and LiveData does not. I understand the one of the main objectives of LiveData is to be observed and updates the UI programmatically but for simple updates, Data Binding is very useful.

This issue was already reported (GitHub and Stack Overflow) and first was said that the version 1.0 would have it and now is said that this feature is in development.

In order to use both LiveData and Data Binding, I created a very simple implementation of class that extends BaseObservable:

import android.arch.lifecycle.LiveData
import android.arch.lifecycle.MutableLiveData
import android.databinding.BaseObservable

class ObservableMutableLiveData<T>() : BaseObservable() {

    private var data: MutableLiveData<T> = MutableLiveData()

    constructor(data: T) : this() {
        this.data.value = data
    }

    public fun set(value: T) {
        if (value != data.value) {
            data.value = value
            notifyChange()
        }
    }

    public fun get(): T? {
        return data.value
    }

    public fun getObservable(): LiveData<T> {
        return data
    }
}

So basically my ObservableMutableLiveData is a copy of ObservableField using LiveData to store the model and with this implementation, the layout updates after every model update.

The questions are:

• Is this a bad implementation of LiveData? Does this wrapper "breaks" the functionalities of LiveData, such as be lifecycle-aware?
• In my understanding, LiveData is the new ObservableField. Is this correct?

Answer 1

The Android Studio 3.1 (currently in Canary 6) will fix this issue, since LiveData can be used as observable field:

Updates to Data Binding:

You can now use a LiveData object as an observable field in data binding expressions. The ViewDataBinding class now includes a new setLifecycle method that you need to use to use to observe LiveData objects.

Source: Android Studio 3.1 Canary 6 is now available