I'm getting errors from my New Relic availability monitor, but my SSL Cert seems to be working fine from my machine and according to SSL report (see image)
Here's the error from New Relic:
<domain-name> (connection error (Received fatal alert: internal_error))
The New Relic availabilty monitor works for the Heroku subdomain that this other domain points to.
Here's the SSL report. Thanks for the help.