Search code examples
rubyenumerator

"break" vs "raise StopIteration" in a Ruby Enumerator

If I use Ruby Enumerators to implement a generator and a filter:

generator = Enumerator.new do |y|
  x = 0
  loop do
    y << x
    x += 1
    break if x > CUTOFF
  end
end.lazy

filter = Enumerator.new do |y|
  loop do
    i = generator.next
    y << i if i.even?
  end
end

does it make any difference whether I break out of the generator's loop using

break if x > CUTOFF

vs

raise StopIteration if x > CUTOFF

?

Both seem to work. I imagine break would be more performant, but is raise more idiomatic here?

Solution

  • In Ruby it's considered a bad practice to use raise/fail for control flow as they are really slow.

    So to answer your question raise StopIteration if x > CUTOFF isn't an idiomatic way of breaking from the loop