I am using Telerik Open/Data Access ORM against an ORACLE.
Why do these two statements result in different SQL commands?
Statement #1
IQueryable<WITransmits> query = from wiTransmits in uow.DbContext.StatusMessages
select wiTransmits;
query = query.Where(e=>e.MessageID == id);
Results in the following SQL
SELECT
a."MESSAGE_ID" COL1,
-- additional fields
FROM "XFE_REP"."WI_TRANSMITS" a
WHERE
a."MESSAGE_ID" = :p0
Statement #2
IQueryable<WITransmits> query = from wiTransmits in uow.DbContext.StatusMessages
select new WITransmits
{
MessageID = wiTranmits.MessageID,
Name = wiTransmits.Name
};
query = query.Where(e=>e.MessageID == id);
Results in the following SQL
SELECT
a."MESSAGE_ID" COL1,
-- additional fields
FROM "XFE_REP"."WI_TRANSMITS" a
The query generated with the second statement #2 returns, obviously EVERY record in the table when I only want the one. Millions of records make this prohibitive.
The first query returns the full object defined, so any additional limitations (like Where) can be appended to it before it is actually being run. Therefore the query can be combined as you showed.
The second one returns a new object, which can be whatever type and contain whatever information. Therefore the query is sent to the database as "return everything" and after the objects have been created all but the ones that match the Where clause are discarded.
Even though the type were the same in both of them, think of this situation:
var query = from wiTransmits in uow.DbContext.StatusMessages
select new WITransmits
{
MessageID = wiTranmits.MessageID * 4 - 2,
Name = wiTransmits.Name
};
How would you combine the Where query now? Sure, you could go through the code inside the new object creation and try to move it outside, but since there can be anything it is not feasible. What if the checkup is some lookup function? What if it's not deterministic?
Therefore if you create new objects based on the database objects there will be a border where the objects will be retrieved and then further queries will be done in memory.