Search code examples
pythonsympysolveris-empty

Why am I getting an empty list as my output using solve command?


I am trying to solve an equation using sympy's solve command but my output is an empty list [ ]. The only reason I think this could be happening is because there is no solution but I doubt that is the reason. Anyone know why I am not getting an answer? Thanks!

from sympy import *

class WaterModel:

    def fp_requirement(self, Ws0, Wp0, Wg0):
        greyW = 60.0
        potW = 126.0
        rainW = 17.05

        self.Ws0 = Ws0
        self.Wp0 = Wp0
        self.Wg0 = Wg0

        self.fp = var('fp')

        filt_greyW = self.fp*greyW
        dWg = self.Wg0 - greyW + (1 - self.fp)*greyW + rainW
        dWp = self.Wp0 - potW + filt_greyW 
        F = self.Ws0 + dWp + dWg
        self.fp = solve(F,self.fp)

        return self.fp 

a = WaterModel()
fp = a.fp_requirement(1500, 100, 100)
print(fp)

Solution

  • I tried adding a few tracing statements to your function, just above the call to solve.

        print "dWg\t", dWg, type(dWg)
        print "dWp\t", dWp, type(dWp)
        print "F\t", F, type(F)
        print "self.fp\t", self.fp
        self.fp = solve(F,self.fp)
    

    Output:

    dWg 117.050000000000 - 60.0000000000000*fp <class 'sympy.core.add.Add'>
    dWp -26.0000000000000 + 60.0000000000000*fp <class 'sympy.core.add.Add'>
    F   1591.05000000000 <class 'sympy.core.numbers.Real'>
    self.fp fp
    []
    

    If I'm reading this correctly, your function evaluates the expressions rather than maintaining the symbolic nature of F. Thus, when you issue the solve directive, you're trying to solve a constant for the variable fp. That's why you get no solutions.


    Ah, ha! There it is!

    1500 + 117 - 26 - 60*fp + 60*fp => 1591
    

    With fp out of the equation, there are no solutions.