If I do something like "import selenium" (or any other kind of third party library) in a .py file and then run it from the terminal, it works just fine. But if I make a new file in PyCharm CE and do the same thing, it can't find the library / module.
How can I fix this or get it to point in the right location? I use a Macbook Pro.
You need to setup your project in PyCharm to use the Python interpreter that has your libraries:
Go to: file->settings->project->project interpreter
And select the appropriate interpreter from the dropdown. After selecting an interpreter, the window displays a list of libraries installed on that interpreter; this should further help you make the right selection.