I have the following list
test_list=list(list(a=1,b=2),list(a=3,b=4))
and I want to extract all elements with list element name a.
I can do this via
sapply(test_list,`[[`,"a")
which gives me the correct result
#[1] 1 3
When I try the same with Rs dollar operator $, I get NULL
sapply(test_list,`$`,"a")
#[[1]]
#NULL
#
#[[2]]
#NULL
However, if I use it on a single element of test_list it works as expected
`$`(test_list[[1]],"a")
#[1] 1
Am I missing something obvious here?
From what I've been able to determine it's a combination of two things.
First, the second element of $ is matched but not evaluated so it cannot be a variable.
Secondly, when arguments are passed to functions they are assigned to the corresponding variables in the function call. When passed to sapply "a" is assigned to a variable and therefore will no longer work with $. We can see this by occurring by running
sapply("a", print)
[1] "a"
a
"a"
This can lead to peculiar results like this
sapply(test_list, function(x, a) {`$`(x, a)})
[1] 1 3
Where despite a being a variable (which hasn't even been assigned) $ matches it to the names of the elements in the list.