Is it possible to use instanceof when passing objects between Threads?

Question

I've run into an issue where instanceof works, and then it doesn't. Going into details is difficult, but I think this might be the problem:

Reading this: http://www.theserverside.com/news/thread.tss?thread_id=40229 (search for Thread.currentThread), it seems to imply that, even if the two objects are the same class, if you pass them between threads with different class loaders, instanceof (and isAssignableFrom) might still fail.

This certainly would explain the behavior I'm having, but I was wondering if anyone could verify it?

(I wish the article linked at the beginning of the discussion was still available, but it doesn't seem like it is.)

Answer 1

This has nothing to do with threads, only with class loaders. The same class definition, when loaded by different classloaders, is seen as two different classes by the JVM. So instanceof or casts between the two fail.

So to answer your original question: passing objects between threads loaded by the same class loader is safe and instanceof et al. works fine.

Here is an article about class loading issues.

See also this earlier answer of mine for a way to verify which classloaders are in the game.

Update to Romain's comment

Here is some code to test the behaviour of instanceof, among others:

URL[] urls = new URL[] {new File("build/classes/").toURL()};
ClassLoader loader1 = new URLClassLoader(urls, null);
ClassLoader loader2 = new URLClassLoader(urls, null);
Class<?> c1 = loader1.loadClass("net.torokpeter.Foo");
Class<?> c2 = loader2.loadClass("net.torokpeter.Foo");
Object foo1 = c1.newInstance();
Object foo2 = c2.newInstance();

System.out.println("c1.toString(): " + c1);
System.out.println("c2.toString(): " + c2);
System.out.println("c1.equals(c2): " + c1.equals(c2));
System.out.println("c1 == c2: " + (c1 == c2));
System.out.println("foo1: " + foo1);
System.out.println("foo2: " + foo2);
System.out.println("foo1 instanceof Foo: " + (foo1 instanceof Foo));
System.out.println("foo2 instanceof Foo: " + (foo2 instanceof Foo));
System.out.println("c1.isAssignableFrom(c1): " + c1.isAssignableFrom(c1));
System.out.println("c2.isAssignableFrom(c2): " + c2.isAssignableFrom(c2));
System.out.println("c1.isAssignableFrom(c2): " + c1.isAssignableFrom(c2));
System.out.println("c2.isAssignableFrom(c1): " + c2.isAssignableFrom(c1));
System.out.println("c1.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class): " + c1.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class));
System.out.println("c2.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class): " + c2.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class));
System.out.println("Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c1): " + Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c1));
System.out.println("Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c2): " + Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c2));

And the output is (in Eclipse, Java5):

c1.toString(): class net.torokpeter.Foo
c2.toString(): class net.torokpeter.Foo
c1.equals(c2): false
c1 == c2: false
foo1: net.torokpeter.Foo@360be0
foo2: net.torokpeter.Foo@45a877
foo1 instanceof Foo: false
foo2 instanceof Foo: false
c1.isAssignableFrom(c1): true
c2.isAssignableFrom(c2): true
c1.isAssignableFrom(c2): false
c2.isAssignableFrom(c1): false
c1.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class): false
c2.isAssignableFrom(Foo.class): false
Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c1): false
Foo.class.isAssignableFrom(c2): false

So everything seems to be consistent :-)