Search code examples
javaooprtti

Avoiding RTTI In Java

If I have a superclass, say Animal,

and two subclasses: Zebra and Giraffe,

If I decide to define a Vector of Animals:

Vector <Animal> animals = new Vector();

and I want to say: You can add Giraffes, but you must own at least one Zebra first.

What is the best way to do this without using RTTI? (instanceof)

Solution

  • Define your own class:

    class Animals extends Vector<Animal>
{
   public Animals(Zebra z) { add(z); }
}

    Two additional points:

    • It is recommended to prefer the use of ArrayList over Vector.
    • You may want to override the remove() method to make sure a Zebra always stays in the collection.

    Personally, I would go for a design that does not use inheritance at all. So instead of subclassing vector (or ArrayList) my class will delegate to them:

    class Animals extends 
{
   private final Vector<Animal> inner = new Vector<Animal>();

   public Animals(Zebra z) { add(z); }

   // Delegate to whatever methods of Vector that Animals need to support, e.g.,
   void add(Animal a) { inner.add(a); }

   ...
}