Why do Ruby (2.0) procs/blocks with splat arguments behave differently than methods and lambdas?
def foo (ids, *args)
p ids
end
foo([1,2,3]) # => [1, 2, 3]
bar = lambda do |ids, *args|
p ids
end
bar.call([1,2,3]) # => [1, 2, 3]
baz = proc do |ids, *args|
p ids
end
baz.call([1,2,3]) # => 1
def qux (ids, *args)
yield ids, *args
end
qux([1,2,3]) { |ids, *args| p ids } # => 1
Here's a confirmation of this behavior, but without explanation: http://makandracards.com/makandra/20641-careful-when-calling-a-ruby-block-with-an-array
There are two types of Proc
objects: lambda
which handles argument list in the same way as a normal method, and proc
which use "tricks" (Proc#lambda?). proc
will splat an array if it's the only argument, ignore extra arguments, assign nil
to missing ones. You can partially mimic proc
behavior with lambda
using destructuring:
->((x, y)) { [x, y] }[1] #=> [1, nil]
->((x, y)) { [x, y] }[[1, 2]] #=> [1, 2]
->((x, y)) { [x, y] }[[1, 2, 3]] #=> [1, 2]
->((x, y)) { [x, y] }[1, 2] #=> ArgumentError