Search code examples
.nethaskellf#discriminated-unionobject-to-string

Haskell's "deriving Show" in F#?


In Haskell it is easy to make an algebraic type/discriminated union "displayable" as a string by simply adding deriving Show to the type definition.

In F# I end up writing things like:

type Pos = 
    | Pos of int * int
    override this.ToString() = 
        match this with
        Pos(startp, endp) -> sprintf "Pos(%d, %d)" startp endp

and obviously it gets much worse with more complicated types.

Any way to get something like deriving Show in F#?


Solution

  • F# printing functions such as printf are able to format reasonably any data type if you use the %A format specifier (they use ToString if you specify %O). You can implement ToString using sprintf which returns the formatted string:

    type Pos =  
        | Pos of int * int 
        override x.ToString() = sprintf "%A" x 
    

    This prints for example "Pos (1, 2)" and it works for most of the F# types (lists, unions, records, tuples). It's a bit longer than just adding deriving Show but at least you don't have to implement the printing yourself.