Search code examples
memorylinux-kernelarmhypervisorreserved

ARM: Safe physical memory position (to reserve) for my ARM hypervisor in relation to a Linux/Android guest

I am developing a basic hypervisor on ARM (using the board Arndale Exynos 5250). I want to load Linux(ubuntu or smth else)/Android as the guest. Currently I'm using a Linaro distribution.

I'm almost there, most of the big problems have already been dealt with, except for the last one: reserving memory for my hypervisor such that the kernel does not try to OVERWRITE it BEFORE parsing the FDT or the kernel command line.

The problem is that my Linaro distribution's U-Boot passes a FDT in R2 to the linux kernel, BUT the kernel tries to overwrite my hypervisor's memory before seeing that I reserved that memory region in the FDT (by decompiling the DTB, modifying the DTS and recompiling it). I've tried to change the kernel command-line parameters, but they are also parsed AFTER the kernel tries to overwrite my reserved portion of memory.

Thus, what I need is a safe memory location in the physical RAM where to put my hypervisor's code at such that the Linux kernel won't try to access (r/w) it BEFORE parsing the FDT or it's kernel command line.

Context details:

  • The system RAM layout on Exynos 5250 is: physical RAM starts at 0x4000_0000 (=1GB) and has the length 0x8000_0000 (=2GB).
  • The linux kernel is loaded (by U-Boot) at 0x4000_7000, it's size (uncompressed uImage) is less than 5MB and it's entry point is set to be at 0x4000_8000;
  • uInitrd is loaded at 0x4200_0000 and has the size less than 2MB
  • The FDT (board.dtb) is loaded at 0x41f0_0000 (passed in R2) and has the size less than 35KB
  • I currently load my hypervisor at 0x40C0_0000 and I want to reserve 200MB (0x0C80_0000) starting from that address, but the kernel tries to write there (a stage 2 HYP trap tells me that) before looking in the FDT or in the command line to see that the region is actually reserved. If instead I load my hypervisor at 0x5000_0000 (without even modifying the original DTB or the command line), it does not try to overwrite me!
  • The FDT is passed directly, not through ATAGs

Since when loading my hypervisor at 0x5000_0000 the kernel does not try to overwrite it whatsoever, I assume there are memory regions that Linux does not touch before parsing the FDT/command-line. I need to know whether this is true or not, and if true, some details regarding these memory regions.

Thanks!

RELATED QUESTION:

Does anyone happen to know what is the priority between the following: ATAGs / kernel-command line / FDT? For instance, if I reserve memory through the kernel command-line, but not in the FDT (.dtb) should it work or is the command-line overriden by the FDT? Is there somekind of concatenation between these three?

Solution

  • As per https://git.kernel.org/cgit/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/tree/Documentation/arm/Booting, safe locations start 128MB from start of RAM (assuming the kernel is loaded in that region, which is should be). If a zImage was loaded lower in memory than what is likely to be the end address of the decompressed image, it might relocate itself higher up before it starts decompressing. But in addition to this, the kernel has a .bss region beyond the end of the decompressed image in memory.

    (Do also note that your FDT and initrd locations already violate this specification, and that the memory block you are wanting to reserve covers the locations of both of these.)

    Effectively, your reserved area should go after the FDT and initrd in memory - which 0x50000000 is. But anything > 0x08000000 from start of RAM should work, portably, so long as that doesn't overwrite the FDT, initrd or U-Boot in memory.