What does CompareTo() do? IComparable

Question

I am using IComparable and a IComparer

In the Student class:[IComparable]

    public int CompareTo(Student studentToCompare)
    {
        if (this.Number < studentToCompare.Number)
            return 1;
        else if (this.Number > studentToCompare.Number)
            return -1;
        else
            return 0;
    }

In the StudentCompareName class: [IComparer]

    public int Compare(Student x, Student y)
    {
        return string.Compare(x.Name, y.Name);
    }

With Compare(Student x, Student y) I am sorting the list of students on name.

If I dont use a CompareTo() in the Student-class, I'm getting errors.

I wonder why I need to have a CompareTo() in my main (Student) class, and what does it do? Why do I need to compare first the student number in the Student class and after that I'm allowed to sort on name in the StudentCompareName class?

Answer 1

I am using IComparable and a IComparer

That's the source of the confusion. You only need one of the two - and they'd rarely be implemented in the same class.

IComparable<T> is implemented to give a natural comparison between one object and another. In the case of something like Student, that probably doesn't make sense, as there are multiple ways to compare students. On the other hand, for something like DateTime it makes perfect sense.

IComparer<T> is meant to be a custom comparison - so it makes sense to have a StudentNameComparer which implements IComparer<Student> by comparing the names, for example.