Controller Methods with same name

Question

I have this method who call 2 others methods but i've an error when a execute that code.

public ActionResult CreateOrder(string action, string type)
    {
        /*Some Code*/
        if(MyObject.isOk){
            return RedirectToAction("EditOrder", new { code = ErrorCode, libelle = Description });

        }else{
            return RedirectToAction("EditOrder", new { nordre = NoOrdre });
        }
    }

public ActionResult EditOrder(string nordre)
    {

    }

[ActionName("EditOrder")]
public ActionResult EditOrderError(string code, string libelle)
{

    }

But i get an 404 because the script try to find the "EditOrderError" view.

Answer 1

ASP.NET MVC doesn't allow you to overload controller actions unless they handle different HTTP verbs.

Assuming you're using C# 4, one possible workaround, albeit not a pretty one, is to use optional parameters on a single controller action:

public ActionResult EditOrder(string nordre = null, string code = null, string libelle = null)
{
    if (nordre != null)
    {
        // ...
    }
    else if (code != null && libelle != null)
    {
        // ...
    }
    else
    {
        return new EmptyResult();
    }
}