What's a good metaphor for Dependency Injection?
A metaphor that stuck with me when programming non-DI systems is "a person playing with his/her toys". A person being an object and the person's toys being anything that object creates, stores, initializes, and manipulates. The toys can dispatch events when they reach a certain state, but they know nothing about the person using them; they're just little black boxes with control switches that make up their interfaces. The person can listen for events from the toys and respond by manipulating their interfaces. The person can do whatever he/she wants with his/her toys, but he/she probably shouldn't go meddling with their innards because they might break.
The havoc that DI wreaks upon my metaphor is that it turns the toys into conscious beings that know their owner, the person using them. The toys can manipulate this person, but the person knows nothing of how they work and doesn't even care. The person just owns the toys and expects the toys to manipulate him/her to the toys' own satisfaction.
WTF?? That sounds horrible!!
What is a good mental metaphor they've been using to think of how DI systems work?
The SOLID motivational images are a good source.
- self inside Lua constructors
- What the definition of dependency in UML
- Specify attributes in constructor in Python
- Optimization Nurse Assignment
- What are Mixins (as a concept)
- What is an example of the Liskov Substitution Principle?
- Incompatible pointer types error only on my local machine and not on online IDE
- What is the dependency inversion principle and why is it important?
- Polymorphism on member variables. I know it is not possible, I don't understand this specific case
- Do PHP interfaces have properties?
- Shouldn't __metaclass__ force the use of a metaclass in Python?
- When to return 'this' instead of 'void' in a method and why?
- Kotlin beginner cannot get Response object shape right
- PHP equivalent of friend or internal
- Factory Method: Prevent a class from Direct Instancing
- When is it a good idea to return a const reference in C++?
- Should I use a class or dictionary?
- Define a common interface without dynamic polymorphism
- What's the benefit of having a scope-resolution operator within the language?
- Preventing user from calling Parent functions
- Get all public methods declared in the class, not inherited
- Why can't we change access modifier while overriding methods in C#?
- define multiple methods for comparison at once using the same principle
- How to model simple mass fraction calculation in Modelica using OOP approach?
- Deriving from a concrete class?
- Inheriting from a namedtuple base class
- calling setters from a constructor
- What is the best way to access object of subclass in other subclass?
- Is there a way to set an instance variable without calling a descriptors __set__ method?
- Is there a better way of detecting when attributes are changed than using decorators?