Search code examples
bashshellexportsolarisenv

What's the difference of the command output after inputting the command "env", "export", "set" under Bash Shell in Solaris?

OS: Solaris

Shell: Bash Shell

Scenario: Input the commands separately: "env", "export" and "set" (without any arguments) and there will be a list of variables and values returned.

My question: What's the difference among the returned values after inputting the three commands?

Solution

  • The env and export commands yield the same information, but not in the same format. And bash's export produces a very radically different output from the output of ksh or (Bourne) shell's version. Note that set and export are shell built-in commands, but env is an external command that has other uses than just listing the content of the environment (though that is one of its uses).

    The set command lists the variables you've created. This includes environment variables, regular (non-environment) variables, and function definitions (which we'll ignore here).

    Consider:

    x1=abc
x2=def; export x2
export x3=ghi

    There are two exported variables (x2 and x3), and one regular (non-exported) variable. The set command will list all three; export and env will only list the exported ones.

    The output of the env command is mandated by the POSIX standard. This is simply the variable name and value followed by a newline:

    name=value

    Classically, the Bourne shell simply listed variables the same way for both set and export.

    Korn shell encloses values in quotes if the value contains spaces or other characters that need protection, but otherwise uses the name=value notation.

    The set command in bash generates assignments with the value protected in quotes. However, the output for export is a declare -x var=value with quote protection. The general idea is presumably that you can use export > file followed by source file to reset the environment variables to the values that were in the environment at the time you did the export.

    Summary

    1. Not all shell variables are environment variables.
    2. The set command lists all shell variables and may list functions too.
    3. The export command lists environment variables.
    4. The set and export commands are built into the shell.
    5. The env command with no arguments lists the environment it inherited from the process that executed it.