Search code examples
c++deep-copyreturn-by-value

C++ deep copying with objects


Good morning. I am having trouble understanding the logic behind deep and shallow copying with objects in C++ in a shared project, so I have created the following example.

int main() {
    ObjectAType* objecta = ObjectAType::New();
    ObjectBType* objectb = ObjectBType::New();

    // some operation to populate data members of object a
    objecta->Operation();

    // assume I have accessors to return datamembers of object a
    // I wish to make a deep copy of SOME of those data members into object b
    objectb->AlignWithA(objecta);

    objecta->Delete();
    objectb->Delete();

    return 0;
}

Now given the object b class function as follows:

public:
void ObjectBType::AlignWithA(ObjectAType* objecta) {
    this->ObjectBDataMember = objecta->DataAccessor();
}
protected:
int ObjectBDataMember;

And the data accessor is just something like this within the class def,

public:
int ObjectAType::DataAccessor() {
    return this->ObjectADataMember;
}
protected:
int ObjectADataMember;

I have a few resulting questions.

1) Since in object b, the data member is declared as

int ObjectBDataMember; 

and not as

int *ObjectBDataMember;

why is the data member accessed as

this->ObjectBDataMember

and not as

this.ObjectBDataMember

?

2) Is this a deep or shallow copy?

I apologize if I have left out important bits. I'm not much of a programmer so things like this easily confuse me. The literature has just confused me further. Thank you for your time.


Solution

  • "Why is the data member accessed as this->ObjectBDataMember and not as this.ObjectBDataMember?"

    That's because this is a pointer, and the -> operator follows the pointer that comes before it to access the member that comes after it.

    "Is this a deep or shallow copy?"

    If you mean the copy of the integer variable, you can call that a shallow copy, but there's no need to qualify it as such because int is not a data structure.

    The term "deep copy" refers to a recursive copying of all objects associated to the object being copied: if a data structure S contains member variables which are pointers, deep copying an instance of S (say, s1) into another instance of S (say, s2) means recursively copying each object pointed by variables of s1 so that s2 will be associated to copies of those objects, rather than to the same objects to which s1 is associated (that would be the case for shallow copying).

    Here, you do not have any pointer member variables, so the concept of "deep" vs "shallow" copy loses its meaning in this context.