Search code examples
lispcommon-lispsymbols

How do I convert a string to a symbol for use as a key in the Lisp "assoc" function?

I have this association-list in Common Lisp:

(defvar base-list (list (cons 'a 0) (cons 2 'c)))

I have to call assoc when my argument is of type string.

For the pair (A . 0) I have to convert "a" to a symbol, and for the pair (2 . C) I have to convert "2" to a symbol. How can I do that?

This should work like this: 

CL-USER 28 : 1 > (assoc (convert-string-to-symbol "a") base-list)
(A . 0)
CL-USER 28 : 1 > (assoc (convert-number-to-symbol "2") base-list)
(2 . C)

I tried using intern but got NIL:

CL-USER 29 : 1 > (assoc (intern "a") base-list)
NIL
Solution

  • You were close with intern; you just had the case wrong. Try this:

    > (assoc (intern "A") base-list)
(A . 0)

    Note that here the name-as-string is capitalized.

    Alternately, you could use find-symbol to look for an existing symbol by name:

    > (assoc (find-symbol "A") base-list)
(A . 0)

    The key here is that when you wrote your original defvar form, the reader read the string "a" and—by virtue of the current readtable case—converted the symbol name to be uppercase. Symbols with names of different case are not equal. It just so happens that at read time the reader is projecting what you wrote (lowercase) to something else (uppercase).

    You can inspect the current case conversion policy for the current reader using the readtable-case function:

    > (readtable-case *readtable*)
:UPCASE

    To learn more about how the readtable case and the reader interact, see the discussion in section 23.1.2 of the Hyperspec.